IFT Notes for Level I CFA® Program
R51 Portfolio Management Overview
5. The Asset Management Industry
The asset management industry is an integral component of the global financial services sector. At the end of 2017, the industry managed more than US$79 trillion of assets owned by a broad range of institutional and individual investors.
Asset managers are usually referred to as a buy-side firm since it uses (buys) the services of sell-side firms. A sell-side firm is a broker/dealer that sells securities and provides independent investment research and recommendations to buy-side firms.
Asset managers offer a wide variety of strategies (e.g., emerging market equities or quantitative investing). Some asset managers are “multi-boutique,” in which a holding company owns several asset management firms that offer specialized investment strategies.
Active versus Passive Management
Asset managers can provide active or passive management or both.
- Active asset managers attempt to outperform a pre-determined performance benchmark.
- Passive asset managers attempt to match returns of a pre-determined benchmark.
Traditional versus Alternative Asset Managers
Asset managers are typically categorized as either traditional or alternative.
- Traditional asset managers focus on long-only equity, fixed-income, and multi-asset investment strategies. In traditional asset management, the management fee is based on asset under management.
- Alternative asset managers focus on hedge fund, private equity, and venture capital strategies, etc. Alternative asset managers’ revenue is based on management fee and performance fees (or “carried interest”).
Since many traditional managers are now offering higher-margin alternative products to clients, the line between traditional and alternative managers is becoming blurred.
The majority of asset management firms are privately owned and are structured as limited liability companies or limited partnerships. The publicly traded asset managers are not very common but they have substantial assets under management. Another prevalent ownership form of asset management is asset management divisions of large, diversified financial services companies that offer asset management alongside insurance and banking services.
Asset Management Industry Trends
The three key trends in the asset management industry include the following:
- Growth of passive investing due to low cost for investors and difficulty for active managers to generate ex ante alpha in more-efficiently priced markets.
- “Big data” in the investment process: Big data refers to massively large datasets and their analysis. These data include
- Structured data i.e. order book data and security returns.
- Unstructured data i.e. data generated by a vast number of activities on the internet and elsewhere (e.g., compiled search information).
- Advanced statistical and machine-learning techniques are being used by asset managers to help process and analyze these new sources of data. Third-party research vendors are supplying new sources of data, including social media data (i.e. data provided by Twitter and Facebook) and imagery and sensor data (e.g., weather conditions, cargo ship traffic patterns and company-specific considerations like retailer parking capacity/usage, tracking of retail customers).
- Robo-advisers in the wealth management industry: It refers to use of automation and investment algorithms to provide several wealth management services, such as investment planning, asset allocation, tax loss harvesting, and investment strategy selection. They key drivers that are leading to rapid growth in robo-advisory assets include growing demand from “mass affluent” and young investors, lower fees, and new entrants’ opportunities owing to low barriers to entry.
6. Mutual Funds and Pooled Investment Products
Pooled investments are where money is collected from several individual investors to be invested in a large portfolio. As the name implies, it is pooling money together for an investment. The funds where this collected money is invested could range from mutual funds to private equity depending on the risk, capital required, strategy, and how it is managed. The different types of investment products generally available to investors are listed below:
|Investment Products by Minimum Investment|
|Investment Product||Minimum Investment|
|Mutual Funds||$50 +|
|Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs)||$50 +|
|Separately Managed Accounts||$100,000 +|
|Hedge Funds||$1,000,000 +|
|Private Equity Funds||$1,000,000 +|
In the rest of this section, we understand what a mutual fund is, the different types of mutual funds, and how other investment products are different from mutual funds.
6.1. Mutual Funds
A mutual fund is a comingled investment pool in which each investor has a pro-rata claim on the income and value of the fund.
Consider the following example: An investment firms raises $100,000 for a stock-based mutual fund from five investors and issues 10,000 shares. Each share has a value of $10. There are three individual investors and two institutional investors. The number of shares is based on the amount invested relative to the total amount.
|Investor||Amount Invested||% of Total||Number of Shares|
Assume the $100,000 is invested in various stocks and it grows to $150,000. The value of each share goes up by 50% to $15. The advantage of this structure is that the investment firm can have one or two managers managing this entire pool of money and each individual investor need not hire a manager to manage his relatively small amount of money. This is a cost-effective way of managing money.
Advantages of Mutual funds:
- Low investment minimums
- Diversified portfolios
- Daily liquidity
- Standardized performance and tax reporting.
In the context of mutual funds, it is important to understand the following terms:
- Net asset value: Net asset value = value of assets – liabilities. The value of a mutual fund is called the net asset value. It is calculated on a daily basis based on the closing price of the stocks held in the fund’s portfolio. The NAV per share is calculated as: NAV/number of total shares. The NAV per share in our previous example was $100,000/10,000 = $10 per share
- Open-end fund: A mutual fund with no restrictions on when new shares can be issued or when funds can be withdrawn. The fund accepts new investment money and issues additional shares at a price equal to the net asset value at the time of investment. Similarly, when an investor redeems shares, the fund sells the underlying assets/securities to retire so many shares at the current net asset value. Because of this, an open-end fund trades close to NAV. NAV is based on closing prices. They can be bought/sold only once during the day. They are also called evergreen funds.
- Closed-end fund: Unlike open-end fund, in a closed-end fund, no new investment money is accepted. Shares of closed-end funds trade in the secondary market. A new investor may invest in the fund if an existing investor is willing to sell his shares. So, the outstanding shares stay the same. Since there is no liquidation of underlying assets and the share base is unchanged, the NAV may trade either at a premium or discount to net asset value based on the demand for shares. The units issued by closed-end funds trade like regular shares – they can be bought or sold on margin, shorted, etc.
Mutual funds can also be classified into:
- No-load fund: Most mutual funds have an annual fee for managing the fund, which is a percentage of the fund’s net asset value. In a no-load fund, only an annual fee is charged, but there is no fee for investment or redemption.
- Load fund: A percentage is charged for investment or redemption or both (called entry and exit load) in addition to the annual fee.
6.2. Types of Mutual Funds
Funds can be categorized based on types of assets they invest in:
- Money market – taxable or non-taxable: They invest in high quality, short-term debt. Taxable money market bonds invest in corporate debt and federal government debt, while tax-free bonds invest in state and local government debt.
- Bond mutual funds – taxable or non-taxable: They invest in a portfolio of individual bonds and preference shares.
- Stock/index mutual funds – domestic or international: They invest in a portfolio of stocks or index funds.
- Hybrid/balanced funds – They invest in both stocks and bonds.
Funds can be categorized as actively managed or passively managed:
- With actively managed funds, the manager tries to identify securities which will outperform the market; these funds have high fees relative to passively managed funds.
- With passively managed funds, the manager purchases the same securities as a benchmark index. This helps ensure that the performance of the fund is similar to the performance of the benchmark.
6.3 Separately Managed Accounts
- A separately managed account (SMA) is an investment portfolio managed privately for an individual or institution by a brokerage firm or individual investment professional (financial advisor).
- Also called managed account, wrap account, and individually managed account.
- SMAs are managed exclusively for the benefit of a single individual or institution to meet their needs with respect to objectives, risk tolerance, and constraints.
- Unlike a mutual fund, the assets of an SMA are owned directly by the individual or institution.
- The required minimum investment in SMA is much higher than that for a mutual fund.
6.4 Exchange Traded Funds
Like mutual funds, ETFs are a pooled investment vehicle often based on an index. With index mutual funds, investors buy shares directly from the fund. With ETFs, investors buy shares from other investors.
How ETFs work
A fund manager creates the ETF by determining what assets the ETF will hold. Once the securities are decided, the fund sponsor contacts an institutional investor who owns those securities. The institutional investor deposits the basket of securities with the fund sponsor (held through a custodian), and in return, receives creation units for the deposited securities. The creation units typically represent 50,000 to100,000 ETF shares.
It is important to note that the weight of securities deposited is often in the proportion of what it is trying to represent. For example, the weight of Athena Health in iShares Russell 2000® Growth Index Fund is 0.61%, and it is roughly the same as in Russell 2000® Growth Index. The institutional investor then sells the creation units as ETF shares to the public; investors buy shares from other investors, so it works like a closed mutual fund. The institutional investor may redeem the original securities by returning the ETF creation units.
How ETFs are Similar to Mutual Funds
ETFs combine features of closed-end and open-end funds:
- Trade like closed-end mutual funds; can be shorted and bought on margin.
- Because of unique redemption procedure, their prices are close to net asset value like open-end funds.
- Expenses tend to be low relative to mutual funds but brokerage fee needs to be paid.
- Unlike mutual funds, ETFs do not have capital gains distributions and the minimum required investment in ETFs is usually smaller than that of mutual funds.
6.5 Hedge Funds
Hedge funds are private investment vehicles that typically use leverage, derivatives, and long and short investment strategies.
Characteristics of hedge funds:
- a. Short selling: Many hedge funds use short-selling directly or synthetically using options, futures, and credit default swaps.
- b. Absolute return seeking: Hedge funds seek an absolute, positive returns in all market environments.
- c. Leverage: Most of the hedge funds use financial leverage (bank borrowing) or implicit leverage (using derivatives).
- d. Low correlation: Some hedge funds tend to have low return correlations with traditional equity and/or fixed-income asset classes.
- e. Fee structures: Hedge funds typically charge two distinct fees: a traditional asset-based management fee (AUM fee) and an incentive (or performance) fee.
6.6 Private Equity and Venture Capital Funds
Private equity and venture capital funds are privately held and actively managed equity positions. In such funds, a firm makes an investment in a company and then is actively involved in the management of that company. The equity they hold is private and not traded in public markets. The intention is to exit out of the investment in a few years. Like majority of alternative funds, private equity and venture capital funds are structured as limited partnerships between the fund manager, called the general partner (GP), and the fund’s investors, called limited partners (LPs). The revenue of these funds comprises of:
- management fee (fees based on committed capital or net asset value or invested capital)
- Transaction fees
- Carried interest: GP’s share of profits (typically 20%)
- Investment income. Profits generated on capital contributed to the fund by the GP.